Wednesday 24 October 2018

OUGD601 - Tutor feedback

After discussing the ideas of the essay and the practical outcome during tutorials, several stages of the investigation could be established. By dividing a timetable plan of the essay, it would be a more efficient way to search for certain elements to include in the essay. This includes looking into different theories of masculinity and the views opposing or supporting the theorists. By doing this, each theory can be validated in terms of its legitimacy. The discussion also led to ideas of innovative approaches and systematic approaches when researching each topic in the essay. This will help to structure the sections of the argument and make it easier to back up certain claims.

Discussion/Reading material 


  • how do people talk about masculinity and gender?
  • is there more of a focus on body image or gender?
  • find more theories of masculinity, including hegemonic masculinity.
  • R. W. Connell
  • Tim Carrigan - A new sociology of masculinity
  • Gender: A power of the person
  • Gilbert Herdt - Guardians of the flutes (1981)
  • Idioms of the past and their relation with today
  • The role class plays in this
  • Michael Messner - Power at Play (1992)
  • In a fitness environment, who is the competitor? 

OUGD603 - statement of intent

Themes subject matter:
  • packaging design
  • commercial advertising
Research methodologies: 
  • could be conducted through research of past briefs
  • other submissions to competition briefs
  • for larger projects, it might be necessary to conduct primary research through interviews or surveys
  • aesthetic analysis to use for inspiration
Statement of intent

During the course of OUGD603, my aim will be to look into the ways in which design is used commercially, competitively and professionally. Some of the subjects that are likely to be explored in the projects will include packing design, commercial use of design, advertising campaigning, printing methods, marketing of work and selling work. In order to fully explore these avenues, it will first be necessary to create a timetable plan of the projects between October and December and then January to May. This way several of the smaller briefs can be managed and explored toward the end of the year. Some of the smaller briefs to look into may include competition briefs that are made with the intent of becoming commercial works, cover art briefs and collaborations with other students. This way the smaller briefs can be managed in a way that utilises research methods, including looking at past submissions to competitions or analysing similar works of art.

Some of the contexts that I may plan to explore further include, societal values, gender roles, marxism and technology, as I have previously looked into these subjects during past briefs. In terms of my research led brief, I will be focusing my investigation on youth culture and the way we choose our career paths as a result of conforming to specific groups. The research that is likely to take place will explore human interaction, how we form groups based on interests in certain activities, hobbies and music taste. As a result of these interests, we form identities that carry meaning and enjoy conveying these identities to others. The role of social media has also changed the way youth culture is today, with the majority sharing their identity online as a way to validate their personality. As my research led brief will relate to the context of practice 3 essay, it will be easier to cross reference certain findings about identity and how it impacts our lives. For some of the other briefs in the module, I will be using personal interests as a starting point for the investigations. For example, I'm interested in politics and persuading others to be more politically involved. Therefore, one of my briefs will aim to propose a solution to the ways we involve ourselves in politics and encourage younger generations to become more actively involved in political debate, beyond the confines of social media.

In terms of how this will benefit my practice in the end, I plan to be able to learn new skills and build on the ones I already have. This will include a better understanding of professional approaches to packaging and the necessary design choices required, as well as ways to work both independently and in collaboration with others of different skill sets. One way that I plan to make the module different from others, would be to utilise professional photography, printing or binding methods, as a way to present the final outcomes as professionally as possible. As a result of the briefs, I plan to be able to gather aesthetic inspiration for my portfolio and necessary commercially creative pieces that will benefit my interviews at the end of the course. 

Tuesday 23 October 2018

OUGD601 - Essay plan

After gathering several sources of research for the essay and receiving feedback from the presentation, creating a plan of the essay will be the next step in the investigation. At times the plan for the essay is likely to change, as there are other sources that will need to be looked at and analysed. By dividing the plan into sections of discussion, the essay will be able to gather valid argument and use other points to back up each claim.

Points of discussion

  • The meanings of masculinity
  • Masculinity through generations
  • Identity
  • gender roles
  • gym culture
  • fitness attraction
  • link between masculinity and muscularity
  • masculine design
  • products for men

OUGD601 - Initial statement of intent

For my context of practice investigation, the focus of the study will be to look at how masculinity influences the world of fitness, the attitudes society has towards the fitness industry and how this may be changed in the near future. By understanding first what meanings masculinity has had over time and its current state, it will be possible to adapt an appropriate practical response that offers an alternative to the problems that masculinity may cause in society.

To begin researching the topic, it was important to gather different sources of information and the theories people had of masculinity. This way, a better understanding of where the problems in society and the fitness industry in particular, lie. Some of the research methods would include comparisons between texts written at different time periods, researching fitness in the media, researching independent studies and the values we hold in society. It may also be worth noting that if necessary, a survey of men could be conducted in a fitness environment. This way a better understanding of the current state of masculinity may be identified.

In conclusion to the investigation, a practical response will be made that will either expose masculinity for what it means or it could be used as a way to offer alternative views of how masculinity will adapt in the future. Through the use of either digital applications or personalised branding, a suitable response to the investigation can be made. This will mean researching fitness products, branding, packaging and marketing so that a conclusive response can be appropriated.

In terms of the theoretical and contextual references in which to place the investigation, there are several areas that may be appropriate for the discussions, including materialism, media influence, societal norms and values, social psychology and masculinity. By identifying theories of masculinity first, it is then easier to discuss these views and compare them with other theories so that a link between masculinity and fitness can be established.

To gather the information for the investigation, several books and articles will be analysed and discussed so that the legitimacy of each claim or theory can be established. Using the blog will allow for each book to be analysed separately and for quotes or theories to be highlighted to use in the essay. If a primary research method is needed for the investigation then it is likely to be recorded using a survey or through individual interviews with participating subjects.

The end result of the investigation will show a reflection on masculinity and its influence on the fitness industry. It also intends to conclude theories of where masculinity is headed in the future and how this may also change the attitudes towards fitness.

Monday 22 October 2018

OUGD601 - Grayson Perry - The Descent of Man analysis

After discussion about some of the topics that would be covered in the essay, it was established that by looking at some of the core reasons behind society's drive for fitness, it may be possible to better understand the industry. Therefore, by researching masculinity it would reveal how men are perceived and how they perceive one another in a time of constant change. One book that look at the issues of masculinity in wider contexts was Grayson Perry's 2016 book, The Descent of Man. I found this to be a hugely insightful look at the 'modern man' and how we establish the requirements, ideals and characterisation of different men.

Chapter 1 - If it ain't broke don't fix it
page 4 - 'For males, being masculine, acting in a manly way, is unquestionably a biological part of them as their penis and testicles and deep voice. But masculinity is mainly a set of habits, traditions and beliefs historically associated with being a man.'

'We need to shift away from seeing masculinity as a closed set of behaviours and from seeing change as threatening, unnatural and feminizing. I see masculinity as being how men behave at present. I think it needs to change to include behaviours that are at present regarded by many as feminine, behaviours that are sensible, life enhancing and planet-saving.'

Chapter 2 - Asking fish about water
In the second chapter of the book, Perry goes on to talk about a characterisation of what he calls the 'Default Man'. The Default Man is a white, middle-class, heterosexual and usually middle-aged man who is likely to fit into the high-status, high-earning and high-power roles of society. This caricature imagined by Perry is a symbol of the man that society perceives to be one of the more desirable masculine figures. Through identifying him in this way, it is clear to see how there is an imbalance and power difference in male dominated society, with many of the highest paid jobs and powerful positions in governments being controlled by men.

page 22 - 'A move away from the long dominance of the Default Man is happening, but slowly. Across the world, political correctness is morphing from 'madness' into common sense. Equality must change from feeling disruptive to feeling necessary and comforting. We need to reconfigure what it is to be masculine, so that men can handle an equal society. One could argue that with its impulse to dominate, masculinity is at odds with modernism and its drive towards a fair society.'

page 31 - 'The Industrial Revolution cemented masculine dominance. In pre-industrial society, men mainly worked close to home; now men went out to work, and eventually this led to the public realm being more associated with men and masculinity, while the home became the sphere of women and femininity. Some men's rights campaigners have since gone on to blame what they see as the feminizing of men on the fact that women have had to bring up boys on their own for much of the time, while conveniently forgetting that, as with the vast majority of huge changes in society, the Industrial Revolution was driven, conceived and controlled by - you guessed it - men.'

Page 40 - ' On one side of the debate around the crisis of masculinity there is often a call to reassert a 'natural' embodied masculinity that will last and be relevant for all time. This noble beast is just a Tarzan call away from the contemporary male benighted by modernity, and is ready and waiting to rescue and revive the feminized male masses, We see this vision of masculinity rearing its head on TV programmes fronted by the likes of Bear Grylls or Ray Mears.'

Chapter 3 - The department of masculinity
Page 51 - Grayson talks about the way in which traditionally men are expected to dress a certain way and any attempt to mimic the shopping and styling behaviours of women is seen as unnatural. He writes, 'The strict code of old-school masculinity, where shopping for clothes feels feminized, is absorbed at a young age. The idea that you can buy the role off the peg assaults the unconsciously held notion that the man is the authentic, natural, uncorrupted one.' 'The female wardrobe is seen as one big extraneous addition, all artifice, hairdos, make-up, frills and heels, while men's clothes are entirely necessary for function and little more.'

page 54 - Grayson has a theory that gender roles could be seen as a performance, that men have a choice in the way they act and do so in ways that signal to others the nature of their gender. For example, he talks about the way in which some men will openly showcase certain traits of 'typical masculinity' through means of either extreme bodybuilding. He says they do this because it signals to other males just how 'masculine' they are. He says 'I often look at men and think that they seem to be victims of this drive to perform their gender. What are they afraid of? Why do they play the man so extremely, whether with muscles or knowledge or wit?' 'Though men might plead that their muscles, big cars and sharp suits are for attracting women, really they are for impressing male rivals.'

Page 86/87 - Grayson talks about a group of youths in Skelmersdale in comparison to tribesmen and their tendency to be violent to rival gangs.





Saturday 20 October 2018

OUGD601 -COP3 - Proposal


COP 3 proposal updated

Research question – Is design responsible for the social changes and attitudes towards the fitness industry?

Topics to discuss
  • fitness and health industry
  • the views of masculinity through time
  • body image and reinforced media ideals
Rationale – Researching the fitness industry and its core drivers will reveal the role that graphic design may play in the communication of products and services to customers. The intention of the investigation will be to acknowledge trends and what effects they may have on society, including how masculinity is viewed in relation to fitness. As a result, it will be possible to understand opinions of the fitness industry and whether or not it will lead to positive development in future.

Contexts – In order to fully understand different views of the fitness industry, it may be necessary to gather research from political contexts, such as the way in which brands may use current affairs as a marketing strategy. It may also be necessary to look at social contexts when researching the fitness industry, as it will provide different viewpoints from different social settings.

Theoretical approach

Theory 1 – Redefining masculinity will mean a change in the way fitness targets male audiences.

Theory 2 –  With time, masculinity takes on new meanings and connotations. Fitness for men is currently seen as a masculine trait in modern society.

Methods - In order to get an understanding of the changes in the fitness industry, it would be beneficial to analyse text from different points in time. By analysing discourses in this way, it may be possible to better understand why fitness has become what it is in the current world and why there are certain connotations relating to the topic. Through primary methods such as surveys and discussions, it may also be possible to understand what the fitness industry means to people today and what could potentially be improved about it.

Practical - As a result of the findings in the investigation, the ideas may be applied to an existing product market. For example, building a brand that sells supplements or fitness related clothing. To do this, research will be required on the types of design used in creating these products and the materials and methods used to make them.

Resources - Most of the design of the potential products are likely to be done using a computer software, while production methods may include fabric printing or embossing on other materials.

Books
  • Fitness, Technology and Society: Amusing Ourselves to Life - Brad Millington
  • The Descent of Man - Grayson Perry
  • Masculinity, Femininity and Male Body Image: A Recipe for Future Research - Stuart B. Murray & Stephen W. Touyz

Wednesday 17 October 2018

OUGD601 - The Stigma of Masculinity by Aqualus M Gordon

The Stigma of Masculinity
Can men still be manly without feeling ashamed?
In this 2014 article by Aqualus M Gordon, there is a comparison made between how masculinity once was and how it is today. When asking male participants to say what the manliest thing about them was, many gave responses that showed they were not afraid to expose a traditionally stigmatised "feminine side". Some of the responses include "my heart", "my ability to show emotion" and "my venerability". This goes to show that over time the traditional expectations of masculinity and its traits are beginning to change in a more accepting society. Gordon goes on to then say, 'just a few decades ago, a man’s admission of sympathy or compassion was more likely to be met with ridicule and social disapproval' and suggests that the traditionally masculine traits could often be disregarded. This includes traits such as competitiveness, protectiveness, assertiveness and confidence, which if disregarded would mean a definitive change in the nature of masculinity.

Tuesday 16 October 2018

OUGD601 - Gender and Popular Culture by Katie Milestone and Anneke Meyer

Page 4 - The media are central to popular culture in many ways. The media are symbolic institutions because their products signify. Media texts construct meanings through the use of language and images.

The term 'new media' refers to media such as the internet, email, digital radio and television, podcasts and video podcasts, blogs, wikis and websites, MP3 players and iPods, to name but a few. The new media can be defined as information and communication technologies (ICTs).


OUGD602 - CreativeRace Studio

Over the summer, I attended CreativeRace studios for 2 weeks after being offered a place during two weeks. This was between June 4th and June 15th, 2018. Here I was able to shadow some of the graphic design team and gain insight into the way they work collaboratively with other departments. For example, I was given the task of gathering research and printing contact sheets, before attending the group meetings a couple times a week. Although the experience was insightful, I did find that this was not the most inclusive as I had expected. This was likely due to Simon Thorpe's busy schedule and the constriction of time they had when completing their current briefs.

However, I do feel that this has allowed me to see what life is like at a design studio and the sorts of work they produce.

Monday 15 October 2018

OUGD603 - "Tell A Lie" Convincingly - Outcome

Outcome 
As a result of our social experiment, we were able to entice 27 people in under 30 minutes to sign up for the competition. This meant that almost 1 person would be signing up per minute that we were stood outside. As we allowed people to sign up we also noticed that no one was willing to read the terms and conditions and instead chose to enter their personal details, including phone number, email address and full name. This goes to show that for a competition that appealed to the student population, it was easy to obtain personal information about people and how they would be unaware of the use of their data. Within 24 hours of beginning the task, we were able to connect with over 50 followers on Instagram, create a uniform to wear on the day, create a poster, brand identity and believable sign up sheet which allowed for the idea to become more authentic. 

Presentation 













Sunday 14 October 2018

OUGD603 - "Tell A Lie" Convincingly - Idea Development

Instagram posts
Using photoshop and Illustrator, we were able to create several posts that would show the business to be authentic and believable. These posts were similar in style to other coffee establishments and would be branded with the identity of Cipher.







From creating an Instagram account for Cipher Coffee, we learnt that by tagging other establishments and setting our location we were able to inform our target market were we would be. From this, people were able to meet us and sign up to the false competition.

We were also able to show the Instagram account to people in person, so that they would follow and see regular updates throughout the week. The Instagram name had also been displayed on the t-shirts made by other members of the group, including a hashtag for people to use in order to reach the account.

OUGD603 - "Tell A Lie" Convincingly - Research

Idea
As a group of 4, we were tasked with creating a convincing lie that would expose a problem. After brainstorming several ideas, we thought about the promotions given to freshers during freshers week and the ease at which people will sign up to receive a chance to win a competition. Therefore our idea was to create a coffee brand that would offer people the opportunity to win free coffee for a whole year. In order to be entered into the competition, participants would sign up to a false newsletter that would give them the option to read false terms and conditions. The terms and conditions would in fact state that the competition was false, which would give us the opportunity to record whether people would bother to read this an understand where their information would be used.

Research
In order to create a brand that was believable we would need to look at existing brands of a similar type and how they would market to their audience, as well as the things they would offer. The role that I would be tasked with was to look at how social media is used by businesses in Leeds and replicate this with our own false social media accounts. After looking through Instagram, Facebook and Twitter, it was clear that the best platform to use would be Instagram as many students were easily able to access and interact with these businesses.

One source for this research was the Wolfox Cafe's Instagram as it would provide our social media with inspiration for a professional looking business. Many of the posts on their Instagram were of coffee, lunches and other snacks available, all of which would look professionally photographed or edited. This works well for the platform as the followers were giving positive feedback to the account and its content.







The Instagram account
After discussion among the group we had settled on the name Cipher Coffee, as it meant false or non-existent making it a fitting name for a false business. To create the Instagram account an email was first set up for Cipher and then linked to a Facebook account, giving it more authenticity as well as an alternative platform to connect with. Making the posts for the account meant finding free images of coffee that could be used to promote the business in a professional manner. The photographs were labelled with the logo that had been created by other members and then posted to the account. One trend that had proved to be popular among several Instagram accounts was to post images within a grid format on the home page. This technique allows each photograph posted to be a part of a bigger picture split into 9 posts when viewed from the home screen.







Thursday 11 October 2018

OUGD601 - Feedback 11/10/2018

After researching different reasons behind people's pursuit of fitness, there were several problems that were addressed. This included the eating disorders that people had and what they typically meant in terms of masculinity and femininity. As a result, several ideas came about that could be discussed and analysed including the idea to begin the essay looking at the reasons for people's pursuit of a body-image, why the ideal body's are what they are and how the media capitalises on this image.

During the discussion, it was brought up that there is a difference in the ways that body image ideals have changed over time and the fitness industry today is more centred on selling these ideals that ever before. Some things that may appear in the essay could include suggested ways that the industry could be changed for a more positive pursuit of fitness and to give people more appropriate expectations of body image. As a result of the essay it may then be possible to create something that will present these principles in a way that is personal to each person. For example, instead of using a body type that is unrealistic and highly unachievable to some, an app could be created that would utilise body statistics of individuals in order to imagine a body image that would be achievable through a personal meal and exercise plan.


OUGD601 - Researching the links between masculinity and body image

Masculinity, Femininity and Male Body Image: A Recipe for Future Research - (Stuart B. MurrayPhD.,* and Stephen W. Touyz PhD, 2012)

Sexual Orientation


  • (Triggemann et al, 2007) suggests that the elevating pursuit of masculinity may be more important among gay men, which (Levesque & Vichesky, 2006) suggest indicates a change in the attitudes towards physical wellbeing and health among homosexual males following the HIV/AIDS epidemic of the gay community. 
  • In contrast, (Kemini et al, 2005 & Yelland and Triggemann, 2003) also say there is research that suggests there is an elevated drive toward both thinness and muscularity.
  • In addition, more contrasting evidence by (Olivardia et al, 1995 & Touyz et al, 1993) report that homosexual males are no more likely than their heterosexual counterparts to experience body dissatisfaction. This further suggests that sexual preference may not exclusively mediate the directional divergence of body image dissatisfaction among males.
Analysis - Triggemann, Levesque and Vichesky all indicate that there may be some evidence to suggest a link between sexual preference and the drive to achieve a particular body type. However, there is contrasting argument as to whether this drive is more so towards thinness or muscularity among men. In addition to this, finding by Olivardia say that there is no difference in the amount of males, both homosexual and heterosexual who experience body dissatisfaction. 

In order to break down the analysis of these conflicting findings, the next chapters looks at femininity and masculinity respectively.

Femininity
  • (Lakkis et al, 1999) suggests that gender orientation accounts for significantly more variance in eating and body image concerns than sexual orientation in men.
  • (Meyer et al, 2001) suggests there is a link between body dissatisfied males who endorse greater feminine gender roles and the desire to have a thinner rather than larger body. This further suggests a link between thinness-orientated eating disorders and femininity in males.
  • (Winston et al, 2004) found that one group of researchers suggest males who present a diagnosis of anorexia nervosa should be offered a rigorous screening for gender identity disorder.
Masculinity
  • (Murray et al, 2011) The pathological pursuit of muscularity is inclusive of a central eating disordered component, which is largely oriented towards the over-regulated consumption of protein-rich foods, rather than the restriction of caloric foods.
  • (Murray et al, 2011) The use of anabolic steroids have been associated with the endorsement of masculine gender roles, which is seen as part of a bigger constellation of muscularity-oriented psychopathology.
  • (Murray et al, 2011) thinness-oriented body image concerns were also reported to have similar psychological and physiological functions as muscularity-oriented eating pathology.
Analysis - After different research investigations looked into feminine and masculine traits among males, it had been found that the majority of males that displayed certain thinness-oriented eating disorders were also likely to display feminine traits. In contrast to this, those that displayed muscularity-oriented eating disorders were likely to be pursuing a bigger body, through means of either protein rich foods or performance enhancing drugs. While this does not explain the reason behind people's pursuit of their ideal body type, it does however explain how body-dissatisfied males may have unhealthy ways of achieving the body they desire.